Why is a semicolon required at the end of a tuple struct definition?

help
1

At the end of a struct definition a semicolon is not required. However at the end of a struct tuple it is. Why is that different?

e.g.

fn main() {
  struct User {
     username: String,
     email: String,
  }

  struct Color(i32, i32, i32);
}
2

I'm not sure but I guess that this is just a design choice. I'd actually say it's 50/50 on whether we use the semicolon at the end of a type definition or not:

struct MyStruct {}
enum MyEnum {}

struct MyTuple(());
type List = Vec<usize>;

(Note that this excludes the rarely used union)

3

The consistency comes from the fact that {} always makes ending delimiters unnecessary (including semicolons and commas). for example,

if foo {
    bar;
}

does not require a semicolon after the }, even though it's a statement.

likewise in match statements, the arms that have braces don't require trailing commas:

match x {
    3 => foo,
    4 => { bar }
    5 => baz,
}

the { bar } does not need a comma after it.

1 Like
4

Ah, that makes some sense, but I may want to add that this isn't always true:

let foo = match x {
    0..20 => {None}
    20..40 => {Some(false)}
    _ => Some(true)
}; //<-- We need a semicolon here

although in this case it's because we're treating it as an expression, so maybe it doesn't fit your argument...

1 Like
5

This. The ; isn't delimiting the end of the match, it's delimiting the end of the expression as a whole (which is also the end of the statement).

Also, don't forget that a generic struct can have a where clause which comes after the parentheses. The ; helps tell the parser if it should expect more or not.

1 Like
6

Because the where clause goes in a different place:

fn main() {
  struct User where {
     username: String,
     email: String,
  }

  struct Color(i32, i32, i32) where;
}

(Yes, that's legal code that compiles.)

4 Likes