Strategy Design Pattern

code review
#1

Hello.
I'm playing with the design pattern - strategy.

I wrote this example:
Rust Playground

Assumptions/Comments:

  • The Converter structure is responsible for the general implementation of the program (common functions).
  • A specific algorithm (strategy) is performed using the DataProcess feature.
  • There will be about 4 specific algorithms.
    (There is no need to create an abstraction factory?)

What else can be improved or changed?

Edit:

  • added commons

References:

#2

I'd consider doing something like this, which allows static dispatch when the strategy is known at compile time:

impl<T:?Sized + DataProcess> DataProcess for Box<T> {
    /* ... */
}

struct Converter<T=Box<dyn DataProcess>> {
    process_behaviour: T,
}

impl<T> Converter<T> where T:DataProcess {
    fn process(&self) {
        // .. any common code 
        self.process_behaviour.process();
        // .. any common code
    }

    fn new()->Self where T:Default { ... }
}

impl Converter {
    fn new_dyn(converter_type: ConverterType) -> Converter {
        /* your earlier new implementation */
    }
}
1 Like
#3

Another alternative, which uses unsized coercion. This might not be possible depending on what other fields Converter has:

struct Converter<T:?Sized = dyn DataProcess> {
    process_behaviour: T,
}

impl<T:?Sized + DataProcess> Converter<T> {
    fn process(&self) {
        // .. any common code 
        self.process_behaviour.process();
        // .. any common code
    }

    fn new(processor:T) -> Self where T: Sized 
    {
        Converter { process_behaviour: processor }
    }

    fn boxed(self) -> Box<Converter> where T: Sized + 'static
    {
        Box::new(self)
    }
}

fn main() {
    println!("Process w/ static dispatch");
    let c = Converter::new(Text);
    c.process();
    
    let c2 = Converter::new(Json);
    c2.process();

    println!("");
    println!("Process w/ dynamic dispatch");
    let v = vec![c.boxed(), c2.boxed()];
    for dyn_c in v {
        dyn_c.process()
    }
}

(Playground)

1 Like
#4

EDIT: